CARSTAR Island Automotive and Collision

I recently had my Toyota Tundra repaired by this company, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From the moment I contacted them, the staff was professional, friendly, and genuinely helpful. The work was done faster than I expected, and when I picked up my truck, the new trim piece looked awesome. They even washed my truck upon my arrival! I highly recommend them to anyone who needs high-quality service. I’ll absolutely be coming back in the future if I ever need help again.

I had an excellent experience with this auto body shop after my Tesla was rear-ended in an accident. From start to finish, their team was professional, efficient, and highly skilled. They repaired my vehicle incredibly fast without sacrificing quality, and the work they did was outstanding—my car looks as good as new. What really stood out was their attention to detail. Not only did they handle the repairs flawlessly, but they also detailed my car beautifully before returning it. It came back spotless, inside and out. Their communication throughout the process was clear, and they made a stressful situation much easier. I highly recommend this shop to anyone needing quality collision repairs. Fast service, excellent craftsmanship, and top-tier customer care.

I gotta say, this body shop in Deer Park is the real deal. From the minute I walked in, the crew was respectful, straight-up, and easy to talk to. No attitude, no runaround, no trying to push extra stuff I didn’t need - just honest people doing solid work. My car came in looking rough, and they brought it back looking fresh, like nothing ever happened. The paint match was clean, the body work was smooth, and the finish came out really nice. You can tell they take pride in what they do and don’t cut corners. What I appreciated most was the communication. They explained what needed to be done, kept things clear, and made the whole process simple. Around here, that matters. A lot of places make you chase them for updates, but these guys were on point from start to finish. The price was fair, the turnaround was better than I expected, and the service felt personal. They treated me with respect and made the whole repair experience way easier than I thought it would be. If you’re in Deer Park, NY 11729, or anywhere nearby, and you need a reliable body shop, this is definitely the spot. Good people, quality work, fair prices, and no funny business. I’d come back here without thinking twice and recommend them to anyone who wants their car fixed right

To my dismay something flew out of another car and hit mine. It was dark and happened so fast. I called my insurance (Allstate) and they were paired with a bunch of auto body shops. I chose CarStar initially because of their location to my house. Upon dealing with them, I would recommend to anybody. They were super accommodating. Very helpful and friendly. My car came back looking like nothing had happened to it. Beautiful work done, great customer service. 10/10 recommend

If I could give this auto body shop a 100 star I would. From stsrt to finish the experience was amazing. And my truck was ready ahead of time! I recommend this auto body shop to anyone in need of the best service!! Trust! The ladies are so amazing and helpful and the entire team is just great!!